CIA improperly used oral instructions to evaluate modernization contract, GAO rules

The agency marked up Markon’s costs by millions based on pre-bid guidance that was never incorporated into the final solicitation. Markon has won another shot at a CIA contract after the Government Accountability Office ruled used unstated evaluation criteria.

The CIA originally awarded the 10-year contract to Arcfield on July 11 for support in areas such as business operations, IT engineering, and business enterprise modernization.

In its protest filed July 23, Markon said the agency conducted unreasonable evaluations of cost realism and past performance.

GAO has since found the CIA marked up Markon’s proposed costs because the company failed to follow oral instructions. During a pre-bid industry session, the CIA told potential bidders not to base their proposals on assumptions about the agency’s modernization plans.

But the CIA never incorporated those instructions into the final solicitation, according to the GAO ruling unsealed Friday.

The CIA argued that it did not need to rely on the oral instructions to make its decision, but GAO did not agree.

“The agency makes this assertion notwithstanding the evaluators’ contemporaneous finding that Markon’s proposed costs were unrealistic because they did not comply with instructions ‘provided in the in-person industry question and answer session,” GAO wrote in its decision.

The CIA source selection authority also wrote that Markon’s proposal was inconsistent with the oral instructions.

“The record fails to support the agency’s assertion that it did not rely on lack of conformance with the oral instructions as the basis for concluding that Markon’s proposal failed to comply with the solicitation’s requirements,” GAO said.

The contracting officer could have included the oral instructions in the final solicitation, but chose not to.

“Because the agency’s oral instructions were not incorporated into the solicitation, it was therefore improper for the agency to conduct its evaluation based on those instructions,” GAO said.

Ironically, the technical evaluation team awarded Markon two minor strengths in its modernization approach with proposed efficiencies being one of them. But the cost team rejected those same efficiencies as unrealistic because they allegedly violated the undocumented oral instructions.

If the CIA had not marked up Markon’s price by millions of dollars, its proposal would have been cheaper than Arcfield’s. GAO redacted both the pricing of the proposals and percentage difference between the two bids.

As for the past performance challenge, GAO denied that part of Markon’s protest and found the CIA’s evaluation was reasonable.

GAO wants the CIA to reevaluate cost realism consistent with the terms of the solicitation and relevant procurement laws and regulations and make a new award decision. Markon also can file for the CIA to reimburse the company for the costs of its protest.

]]> 

  • Special Operations Command seeks AI platform for its acquisition staff
    by Ross Wilkers on November 18, 2026 at 7:13 pm

    The command is seeking a more unified environment and signaling its openness to either working with one prime or a team.

  • Who’s who at Trinzic
    by Ross Wilkers on November 18, 2026 at 4:00 pm

    Michael LaRouche, the CEO-designate, joined the Trinzic business in September after a one-year stint as CEO of Serco Group’s North American subsidiary. His three-decade career in industry also includes senior roles at Science Applications International Corp., Raytheon and Lockheed Martin. LaRouche will also be a member of Trinzic’s eight-person board of directors to be chaired by Wendy Masiello, the retired Air Force general whose 36-year military career culminated with service as director of the Defense Contract Management Agency. Masiello joined the board of KBR in 2017 and will step down from that position upon the spinoff’s completion. Nicholas Veasey, the chief financial officer-designate, started that role in July after six years as MAG Aerospace’s finance chief. His two-decade industry career also includes a stint at Booz Allen Hamilton as vice president of treasury, mergers-and-acquisitions, and investor relations. Other key members of Trinzic’s executive leadership team include: Erik Biebighauser, chief growth officer Doug Hill, president of the U.S. exploration and logistics business Jay Lennon, president of the U.S. defense and intelligence business Todd May, senior vice president of the U.S. exploration and logistics business Paul Shaughnessy, vice president of the U.K. business Nick Maan, vice president of the Australia business Including LaRouche and Masiello, the board of directors comprises: Nchacha Etta, CFO of U.S. Physical Therapy Inc. Carol Hibbard, former CFO for Boeing’s defense business and a 25-year veteran of the plane maker Chance Saltzman, former Space Force chief and 36-year military veteran who retired at general Rakesh Sharma, former Ultra Electronics CEO and three-decade veteran of that company Mark Sopp, former KBR CFO who before that was finance chief at Leidos and the pre-split Science Applications International Corp. James Syring, former Missile Defense Agency director and 32-year Navy veteran who retired at vice admiral ]]>

  • Trinzic previews its post-spin future, which includes an $8B Antarctica program
    by Ross Wilkers on November 18, 2026 at 4:00 pm

    In talking with Wall Street, CEO Michael LaRouche and his colleagues describe space and defense programs as key drivers of its growth.

  • Alliant 3's second round adds two dozen companies
    by Ross Wilkers on November 17, 2026 at 8:08 pm

    The General Services Administration is still evaluating proposals for this flagship “Anything IT Anywhere" vehicle, which has nine positions left to award.

  • One divestiture and a trio of M&A transactions to note
    by Ross Wilkers on November 17, 2026 at 8:03 pm

    Aptim wants to further prioritize government work as Cadmus, LeoLabs and Redhorse Corp. eye new market areas.

  • Trax, Army settle AI evaluation dispute
    by Nick Wakeman on November 17, 2026 at 4:14 pm

    The Army has paid Trax's legal fees and apologized for how it did not fully disclose the use of artificial intelligence in evaluating proposals for missile range support services.

  • L3Harris and the risk small contractors face from big customers
    by Dustin Siggins on November 17, 2026 at 4:11 pm

    Having clients and other key stakeholders in your corner before the blame comes helps build trust and a business pipeline, writes communications guru Dustin Siggins.

  • Mantech lands its largest-ever contract with $2.9B award
    by Nick Wakeman on November 16, 2026 at 8:35 pm

    The company will provide logistics and sustainment support to the U.S. Indo-Pacific Command under a seven-year task order.

  • Forget the election. Your recompete is already being decided.
    by Nic Coppings on November 16, 2026 at 8:32 pm

    Exceptional CPARS ratings and green gate reviews won’t save incumbents who aren’t capturing what the customer tells them on every call, writes growth expert Nic Coppings.

  • Q-CTRL fetches $290M Series C capital in 'AI for quantum' push
    by Ross Wilkers on November 16, 2026 at 7:04 pm

    The group of returning investors includes Lockheed Martin Ventures and In-Q-Tel, respectively the startup investment arms of the defense giant and the intelligence community.

Are you interested?

We Look Forward To Exploring How Our Team Can Help

Please submit the form below. Your information is safe with us and will not share with anyone else.